Wednesday, December 5, 2007

Avoiding the Scarlet "M"

The 1964 book, A Guide to Elegance by Genevieve Antoine Dariaux is an amusing exercise in anachronism, delineating rules for appropriate dress which border on stultifying. It does yield up some gems however, a few of which still hold true. In the section "Age," she says "There is a saying in France, 'Elegance is the privilege of age' - and thank heavens it is perfectly true."

In the days before Fashion seemed to worship exclusively at the altar of Youth, a woman could look forward to achieving an age where more elegant and sophisticated clothing was her due. Now it often feels like we're navigating a narrow space between dowdiness and being branded with an "M" on our not-so-supple cheek should we transgress with attire deemed too youthful.

Reading Linda Grant's article in The Guardian on Monday, I was delighted to see my own style philosophy reflected in her conclusion:

Eternally stylish women find their look and modify it as they grow older; I arrived at the conclusion that to dress well in your 50s and 60s you need to dress more simply, saving the attitude for one item and paring down the rest, so my leather jacket would be worn with jeans and a cashmere sweater, or over a little black dress.

Actually, this has been my style M.O. for several years now, originally born out of frugality and work-appropriateness (in those horrible, oppressive days before it became OK to wear velour track suits to the office /sarcasm o_O ). I learned in my 30's to invest in simple, classic clothing and let accessories (and sometimes jackets) be my "showoff" pieces. This is where I tend to hit my style Sweet Spot and I've rarely gone wrong with this formula.

But I agree with Linda that it's especially true as we move into our 50's and beyond that our favorite leather jacket, or a short skirt, or a Balenciaga motorcycle bag can still work for us, as long as we keep the rest of the ensemble simple. And incorporating current or edgy elements can keep a simple ensemble from looking too stodgy and boring.


But here are some items I assiduously avoid, and think that when worn on most women over 40 tend to look out of sync with our age:
  • White eyelet
  • Babydoll anything
  • An abundance of lace or ruffles
  • Jumpers* or rompers
  • Any combination of tops and bottoms that allows skin to show in between
  • Playboy bunny or mudflap woman jewelry (in fact, these are questionable on women of any age)
  • Hello Kitty, Paul Frank or similarly themed clothing
  • Pants with verbiage across the ass
YMMV, as the kids say.
*"Jumper" in the U.S. is a sleeveless dress designed to be worn over a blouse or sweater. I've recently learned that in British terminology, a jumper is a pullover sweater, with which I have no beef and in fact, own several.
Picture from: www.fashion-era.com/

12 comments:

  1. Even under 40, I think much of your list of glamour "dont's" are true for most people. I don't like baby doll dresses on any adult women.

    There are very few women who can pull off the ruffley "Gypsies, Tramps and Thieves" look and yet many over 40's embrace this look as their version of style. Even 18 year olds, IMHO, look absurd with writing on their derrières.

    20,30,40,50 and beyond all really look best in simple quality pieces. I think it is just easier on the eye and tells a stronger visual story.

    As always, a thought provoking post. :-)
    Merci,
    LBR

    ReplyDelete
  2. Overall, I agree with your list. Jumpers may be acceptable on an exception basis, although in general they're awful. Still, better those than mudflap girls, playboy, and lettering on the back side.

    The ruffly look on older women often reminds me of Bette Davis in "Whatever Happened to Baby Jane".

    ReplyDelete
  3. Amen, Sista! Except, I think that lots of the items on your list look silly on almost all women of any age.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I work on a university campus, and yesterday in the library cafe noticed a young woman with about 6 inches of flesh exposed between the top of her pants and the bottom of her sweater. Firm, smooth, unblemished flesh, but it still didn't look good. Maybe I am a puritan.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Dejapseu:

    That exposed skin thing is amusing to me on many counts. Needless to say sometimes it _is_ a muffin top as we British people say. But in a sari, an exposed 6 inches (or more depending on how long a torso is or whether one is Shilpa Shetty) is de rigeur. Not to say, that there are never any laddoo-rolls there (laddoo is a round, Indian sweet meat).

    PS: I am getting a bit upset with Blogger. The comment choices have changed and I can no longer leave a track to my blog from my comment. Many of my blogger friends have moved seamlessly to Wordpress (where one can import the whole thing lock, stock and barrel in 5 minutes)... I blogged about this of course. As usual. The wrath of the blogger shows up in the blogosphere.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Yes, I've been having some issues with Blogger and am considering a move. A few days ago it was not loading pictures, and now it's not notifying me of comments, so I have to keep checking back. >:(

    Can I keep my domain name (www.unefemme.net) with Wordpress?

    ReplyDelete
  7. Dejapseu: I am sure you can keep your domain name i.e. if you bought it yourself. You can redirect it to your Wordpress blog. You may have to inform all those who have blogrolled you though...

    May be, you want to set up an account on Wordpress and see their help forum? It was seamless and I moved a whole year's Obesity blogging (some 200 posts with pictures, tags, categories etc) and it took about 3-4 minutes.

    ReplyDelete
  8. That's a great list - and I agree with my fellow commenters, I don't think those looks work too well on women of any age. I know I don't wear any of them, and I'm 24.

    ReplyDelete
  9. I'd add overalls, clogs (except maybe in the garden), printed turtlenecks,scrunchies, baseball caps with ponytail pulled through, bags with dangly charms, appliques on clothing, and sleep tees. (It's time to wear beautiful gowns.)

    I love Mme D's remark that she "always dresses grandmothers in gray lace."

    ReplyDelete
  10. I gently disagree with white eyelet. I am 43 and have a nice white eyelet summer skirt. Of course, I keep it simple with a plain top or T-shirt, and white looks good against my skin tone (cafe au lait).

    ReplyDelete
  11. I have received an invitation to a "Hunt Country Ball". The attire is either black tie or "Scarlet". Can you please tell me what is "scarlet" attire? Please tell me I don't have to include a corset :)

    ReplyDelete
  12. lorif - my best guess would be "Scarlett O'Hara", meaning Civil War era hoop skirts. I think as long as you're dressed in the spirit of the occasion, no one will shun you for not wearing a corset. ;-)

    ReplyDelete

Dites moi vos pensées...