Laura Mercier Lip Shine in Crystal Pink, $22.
I loved the coppery pink color of this in the jar. The product itself looks very glossy both in the jar and on the fingertip, and I worried that it would make my lips gleam like a disco ball. But in small amounts, it produces a very lovely and subtle glow, not goopy shine. It looks great over a pale nude or pink lipstick, and also is quite pretty worn alone.